Monday, 23 October 2017

Empathy, Lamps (or, Other Peoples Shoes)

I recently downloaded a "freebie" Ebook, "Empathy" by Raoul Martinez. It was an excellent little read. Quite a lot of detail of how our World Economy "works", based as it is upon "realism" and how the world is considered to work. 





Apparently we just cannot afford empathy - that is, according to the politicians and economists. Another way of saying it is that we must always look after Number One.

We are far here from the verse found in the Buddhist Scriptures:-

Protecting ourselves, we protect others.

Protecting others, we protect ourselves.


Well, possibly there is realism and then there is realism. Does our world actually work the way it is?






There is a story in the Buddhist texts of the Buddha descending into Hell. He carries a lamp. By its light for the first time those there recognise that they are not alone. "Ah, there are others here besides myself!" Such a recognition is the beginning of ethics, morality, empathy. 


What shall we see when we live in the light?


Raoul Martinez, in his book, says that empathy trumps forgiveness. He quotes Jo Berry, who lost her father to the Brighton Bomb. Jo later met with the man who planted the bomb, Patrick Magee, who had been released from prison as part of the Good Friday Agreement. Jo says:- "I don't talk about 'forgiveness'. To say 'I forgive you' is almost condescending - it locks you into an 'us' and 'them' scenario keeping me right and you wrong. That attitude won't change anything . But I can experience empathy.........."


Patrick Magee and Jo Berry

Time again for William Blake's "mutual forgiveness of each vice opens the gates of paradise", which gives the context of forgiveness as mutual and thus not of "us" and "them". 


Compassion - a relationship between equals. An American soldier feeds an orphan kitten during the Korean War.

And Pema Chodren again:- 

Compassion is not a relationship between the healer and the wounded. It's a relationship between equals. Only when we know our own darkness well can we be present with the darkness of others. 





For interest, a video of Jo and Patrick:- 








Thank you

Wednesday, 11 October 2017

Mu, Perfection and Jung Again

My last ramble ended with us all having Buddha nature and the subsequent question:- does a dog have Buddha nature?


Mu

An encircled Mu

The answer, according to a zen master ( Joshu ) is "mu", which freely translated is "nothingness". At mention of nothingness the average mind will think of nihilism and perhaps find confirmation of the opinion that the "east" is a place of empty contemplation, of the Buddha in the lotus position, eyes closed, seeking inward resolution of the world's problems by not moving a muscle.

Maybe not. But at this point my own mind has remembered a poem by Billy Collins, one I have always loved. Here it is:-


Shoveling Snow With Buddha



In the usual iconography of the temple or the local Wok
you would never see him doing such a thing,
tossing the dry snow over a mountain
of his bare, round shoulder,
his hair tied in a knot,
a model of concentration.

Sitting is more his speed, if that is the word
for what he does, or does not do.

Even the season is wrong for him.
In all his manifestations, is it not warm or slightly humid?
Is this not implied by his serene expression,
that smile so wide it wraps itself around the waist of the universe?

But here we are, working our way down the driveway,
one shovelful at a time.
We toss the light powder into the clear air.
We feel the cold mist on our faces.
And with every heave we disappear
and become lost to each other
in these sudden clouds of our own making,
these fountain-bursts of snow.

This is so much better than a sermon in church,
I say out loud, but Buddha keeps on shoveling.
This is the true religion, the religion of snow,
and sunlight and winter geese barking in the sky,
I say, but he is too busy to hear me.

He has thrown himself into shoveling snow
as if it were the purpose of existence,
as if the sign of a perfect life were a clear driveway
you could back the car down easily
and drive off into the vanities of the world
with a broken heater fan and a song on the radio.

All morning long we work side by side,
me with my commentary
and he inside his generous pocket of silence,
until the hour is nearly noon
and the snow is piled high all around us;
then, I hear him speak.

After this, he asks,
can we go inside and play cards?

Certainly, I reply, and I will heat some milk
and bring cups of hot chocolate to the table
while you shuffle the deck.
and our boots stand dripping by the door.

Aaah, says the Buddha, lifting his eyes
and leaning for a moment on his shovel
before he drives the thin blade again
deep into the glittering white snow.




Shovelling snow, or "chop wood, carry water"


Where was I? Perfection - no, actually I wasn't but I started the blog with that word in mind so I will move on from hot chocolate and shovelling snow. The autobiography of Jung I mentioned in my previous blog was called "Wounded Healer of the Soul". The title suggests support for the words of Pema Chodron:- 

Compassion is not a relationship between the healer and the wounded. It's a relationship between equals. Only when we know our own darkness well can we be present with the darkness of others. Compassion becomes real when we recognise our shared humanity.


But relating this to perfection, my own thought is that "perfection" can prove an awful idea. Often involved with the pursuit of perfection is judgement ( of other and oneself ), self hate, and obstructions to appreciating what actually is now and thus stifling gratitude. For me the heart of Reality is Mercy and Grace; how can that heart know itself within the demand for perfection? 



Striving for perfection

"A clearly enlightened person falls into the well. How is that so?"

So, "Your not OK, I'm not OK, but that's OK", or as William Blake said, "Mutual forgiveness of each vice opens the gates of paradise". I think now that seeking the "meaning of it all" is a red herring.

"Love has no why" ( Eckhart )

Love also has no colour, labels, border or religion

Getting back to Jung, he said at one point that "nothing worse can happen to one than to be completely understood"


And.....



" The core of the individual is a mystery of life that is snuffed out when it is 'grasped' " ( a biographer of Jung ) 




Jung and All Things West

I recently read a biography of the psychologist Carl Jung.

Carl Gustav Jung



Jung, possibly looking for his spectacles


Really, I'm not actually looking for a new path ( if "path" is even the correct word to use for my stumbling approach to what is called "life" ) The last thing I need is another set of buzz words - in this case "anima", "archetypes", "individuation", "synchronity" and a few more. All a bit of a jigsaw puzzle needing to be put together to try to sort out the mysterious "self" we appear to experience ourselves as being.  Myself, I like biographies, life stories, and actually find the actual meaning of the buzz words easier to grasp when put into the context of a life as lived and experienced. Letters to friends by the subject of the biography are often another source of insight and illumination. 


An early quote  from Jung's letters caught my eyes so I'll copy it here.....

The journey from cloud cuckoo land to reality lasted a long time. In my case Pilgrim's Progress consisted in my having to climb down a thousand ladders until I could reach out my hand to the little clod of earth that I am.


What will grow from our own little clod?


"The little clod of earth that I am" seems pretty disparaging and in certain contexts could be seen as an expression of low self-esteem. But it IS all in the context. I think that everything must be known and seen in context to be seen at all. Just a case of getting the context right, which can be pretty tricky at times, given our own predilection of thinking ourselves more the diamond in the batch rather than a clod of earth. 

Seen in context, just the once, there, then.

"We all have Buddha nature". I have heard that one a few times. To think so could become a source of pride. But the context is in the "all". All living beings have the same real essential nature. Our personality, culture, our beliefs, are not inherent parts of us; more guests. Alas, we can take great pride in them and see some collections of often accidental conditions as better than others.

"Does a dog have Buddha nature?" is the great question which I will leave with my non-existent readers.





Thank you.

Tuesday, 3 October 2017

My Fertile Period

Rather encouraged by the fact that virtually no one actually reads this, I have the confidence to express myself more. Way back in the past I would attempt to write poetry. However, my "muse" eventually dried up (if it ever had any juice in it at all) and so I just have a small back catalogue. I will blog a few of my efforts here. 






The first is/was my one and only "success", having been read out at the "Old Court" theatre in my home town as one of the top ten in a local competition. Just to add that the reader got it all wrong, reciting the words with a deep serious pomposity that was far from my own rather ironical and ambiguous attitude towards the words. No matter, here is my opus, titled "Before Bacon: An Ode to Despair":-


Oh! I wish I'd been born before Bacon
When the sun still moved in the sky,
When hope was in more than a daydream
And beauty in more than the eye.

When the Great Chain of Being had God at the top
And Old Nic down below in his lair,
When people were burnt for love of their souls
And not just because they were there.

Back in those days before Auschwitz
When there was till trust to betray,
Before Symbol and Myth became Number
And the Cross became DNA.

Oh! I wish I'd been born before Bacon
When Saints trod the Pilgrim's Path,
When people still jumped at a bump in the night
And not at a bump in a graph.

When Crusades were fought for Truths believed
And Faith was the Devils hammer,
Nothingness only the clay God used,
The Absurd a Bishop's stammer!

When Man was seen as something more
Than atoms swirling in air,
Before the face of the Risen Christ
Became the face of despair.

Yes, I wish I'd been born before Bacon
Though there's not much to choose in the end;
But I might have had serfs and a castle
And I might have had Christ as a friend.



The "absurd" - unless, of course, "the journey is home"


Well, on to another, a poem about a young severely handicapped boy who once lived next door to us. His name was George. One day when I left the house his mother was standing beside his pushchair. She was chatting to another lady, who just as I passed reached down and patted the child's head and I heard her say:- "he's a little angel". I remember a feeling of rage at her words which I never understood at the time. But anyway, I wrote this - intentionally naive - little verse:-

see no wings on georgie

else he would be bound

set no seal upon him

place no fences round


see him not for what he could be

what he should or what he would be

see him as he is before you

love the living truth, see georgie


hope for guidance, hold no answers

in the mornings when you wake him

as he casts his eyes upon you

your response can make or break him






I think that the reason I eventually stopped attempting to write poetry was that I discovered the "real" stuff. Which is sad in certain ways. Even though our own attempts are often no more than doggerel they are ours and often seek to express emotions, viewpoints and human empathy. That such is expressed in what in a literary sense is poor is in many ways beside the point. Knowing ourselves and expressing ourselves has a value beyond literary merit as such.

Anyway, as I say I discovered the "real" stuff. Partly due to a guy called Malcolm Muggeridge who had a way with words. He would often quote a couplet or two from William Blake which touched a chord in me. Up until then, and from my experience at school (where the only poems we were introduced to were awful pompous celebrations of the British fighting spirit), the poetry I knew was boring. Blake I found was not boring, and I eventually bought a "Portable Blake" and his "Songs of Innocence and Experience" were genuinely life changing. I moved on from there.


The British Fighting Spirit

While my muse was active (I am joking) I kept a little note book, so my efforts must have meant something at the time. What was strange as I read through them many years later was that I could hardly remember writing some of them. One in particular seemed to come up out of nowhere and was particularly striking in a very emotional way; this because eventually my own mother declined with dementia, and her last three or so years were particularly stressful in many ways. So my words, written before this happened, made me think of those who may have just passed my own mother by as she must sometimes have stood, bewildered and lost.


And When She Had Gone, Pity Came


She seemed to have no yesterdays

And very little else

As she stood alone in the passing crowds

Staring, talking to herself.


I approached her with a numbing dread

Would she turn to me and speak

And isolate me from a kinship made

With all others on that street?


But I had no need to worry -

Her mouth gaped and trembled wide;

So I passed her without a sideways glance

And left her far behind


Yet looked back. She had moved at last

To the pavements edge, still lost -

(I remember thinking how strange it seemed

That she looked before she crossed)


As said above, with my own mother declining with dementia well after I wrote this, it now has more resonance with me. During her decline, mum went out and got herself knocked down by a car. So yes. Makes me think.



Another few of "me poems" and then I will call it a day. The next is called "Palm Sunday", which can mean many things. For me, at the moment, I think of the wars of religion and the inquisitions, the sheer pageantry and might of the so called "ages of faith", and I wonder what it was all about compared to, say, a mothers love for her child. Each to their own.

I was standing on some low ground

Near the road from Bethany

When suddenly the distant sound

Of cheering came to me.


I looked up, saw a distant crowd

Where rocks and roadside met

But what was causing cries so loud

I could not see as yet.


Within my heart a wonder flowed -

A longing to draw near,

Yet as I reached the winding road

I found the way was clear


The cheering crowds had moved away,

Left nothing to be found

But dust upon the beaten clay

And palm leaves scattered round.



What price a cup of tea?


Here we have a ditty written after actually hearing the words "Oh! What an exquisite desk!" in the High Street while feeling, myself, just a little pissed off with life.


"Oh! What an exquisite desk!" she said,
Gushing away from her husband's hand.
Then "Oh! what a lovely four-poster bed!"
(Later the Ming vase on its stand).

So she continued, voice rising shrill,
Straining to wrench life and death apart,
Using American Express to fill
The empty mansions of the heart.



And finally, we all know the programmes where the experts and the analysers all earn their wages summing up the latest "situation".


Those programmes are always the same;
Those Current Affairs programmes are always the same.
The editions that deal with some new war,
Those programmes are always the same.
First the historical background is given;
How historically the conflict arose,
How the crisis began - such information is given.
Then the World Perspective is given;
Everything is put into context.
The conflict is put into focus.
The Superpowers - all are placed in perspective.
The relevant politicians are referred to;
The words and attitudes of the relevant politicians are referred to;
A relevant speech of a relevant politician is referred to.
There is some in-depth analysis.
Then some film is shown of the actual battle area;
The areas actually touched by the conflict are shown.
Where the bombs have fallen - some film is shown.
Then come the women and children screaming.
Then come the women and children screaming.
Then come the women and children screaming.
Then come the women and children screaming.
Then various solutions to the crisis are discussed;
Various proposals for resolving the conflict are discussed.
The various experts discuss the various proposals.
Those programmes are always the same.



No one need be screaming


Protecting oneself, one protects others.
Protecting others, one protects oneself

(Buddhist text)



Butterflies and differentiation

Maybe I have mentioned it elsewhere, maybe not, but  I have for a long time loved butterflies. Way back when I was a lad we saw so many kind...